September 26, 2011
One of the constants throughout my 10 seasons of blogging about the Twins is their inability to develop or acquire middle infielders who can hit. I started blogging in 2002, when the Twins hadn't been to the postseason in a decade, Ron Gardenhire was a rookie manager, and the double-play duo was Cristian Guzman and Luis Rivas. In the 10 years since then they've had 10 different players start at least 100 games at shortstop or second base:
G OPS Nick Punto 430 .652 Cristian Guzman 423 .684 Luis Rivas 359 .686 Alexi Casilla 335 .643 Jason Bartlett 301 .706 Luis Castillo 227 .720 Brendan Harris 160 .666 Orlando Hudson 124 .712 Juan Castro 117 .599 Matt Tolbert 113 .570
During that 10-season span the average American League middle infielder has posted a .730 OPS, yet all 10 of the middle infielders to start at least 100 games for the Twins posted an OPS below .730. In fact, each of the Twins' four most-used middle infielders had an OPS below .690 and the 10-player group combined for a .670 OPS that's 60 points below the league average, with the high-water mark being Luis Castillo's mediocre .720 OPS from 2006 to mid-2007.
Here's how Twins shortstops have ranked in OPS for the 14-team league each year:
YEAR RANK SHORTSTOPS 2002 12th Guzman, Hocking 2003 8th Guzman, Hocking, Gomez 2004 11th Guzman, Punto 2005 14th Bartlett, Castro, Punto 2006 8th Bartlett, Castro, Punto 2007 10th Bartlett, Punto 2008 12th Punto, Harris, Everett 2009 9th Cabrera, Punto, Harris 2010 6th Hardy, Punto, Casilla 2011 13th Nishioka, Casilla, Plouffe, Tolbert
On average during the past 10 seasons Twins shortstops have ranked 10th among AL teams in OPS and the only time they've finished higher than the middle of the pack was last season, when J.J. Hardy's decent .714 OPS helped them rise to sixth and they immediately jettisoned him. Twins shortstops have been above average offensively once in 10 years and even then it was just barely, whereas they've been 10th or worse six times and 12th or worse four times.
And now here's the same list, but with Twins second basemen:
YEAR RANK SECOND BASEMEN 2002 9th Rivas, Hocking, Canizaro 2003 12th Rivas, Hocking, Gomez 2004 7th Rivas, Cuddyer 2005 12th Punto, Rivas, Rodriguez, Boone 2006 9th Castillo, Punto 2007 13th Castillo, Casilla, Punto 2008 10th Casilla, Harris, Punto 2009 14th Casilla, Punto, Tolbert 2010 9th Hudson, Casilla, Tolbert 2011 13th Casilla, Hughes, Tolbert, Cuddyer
Believe it or not the Twins' second basemen have actually been slightly worse than the woeful shortstops, ranking 11th among AL teams in OPS on average during the past 10 seasons and never placing higher than seventh. In those 10 years they've been ninth or worse nine times and 12th or worse five times. And this year both the Twins' shortstops and second basemen are second-to-last among AL teams in OPS.
It's also worth noting that they haven't been any better at finding productive third basemen, at least since Corey Koskie left as a free agent. Koskie was the Twins' starting third baseman from 2000-2004 and on average during those five seasons their OPS at third base ranked fifth in the league. Koskie signed with the Blue Jays after the 2004 season and since then here's how Twins third basemen have ranked in OPS among AL teams:
YEAR RANK THIRD BASEMEN 2005 10th Cuddyer, Rodriguez, Tiffee, Castro 2006 13th Punto, Batista, Rodriguez 2007 14th Punto, Rodriguez, Buscher 2008 11th Buscher, Lamb, Harris 2009 11th Crede, Harris, Buscher, Tolbert 2010 10th Valencia, Punto, Tolbert 2011 9th Valencia, Hughes
Actually that's even uglier than the middle-infield picture. This year is the first time since Koskie left that Twins third basemen have ranked better than 10th in the league in OPS and they're still below average in ninth place. Koskie started 762 total games at third base for the Twins, producing an .839 OPS. In the seven seasons since his departure they've started six different players at least 75 times at third base and none of them have cracked a .750 OPS:
G OPS Nick Punto 246 .653 Danny Valencia 222 .724 Michael Cuddyer 107 .741 Brian Buscher 106 .702 Brendan Harris 86 .688 Joe Crede 84 .729
If you combine their shortstops from 2002-2011, second basemen from 2002-2011, and third basemen from 2005-2011 that's 27 total years of infielders. And in those 27 positional years the Twins have had an above average OPS twice (shortstops in 2010 and second basemen in 2004) and have never finished higher than sixth in the league while ranking 10th or worse 18 times. All of which is a very long way of saying they can't find any infielders who can hit.
As for why they can't find any infielders who can hit ... well, there are a few theories that seem to make sense. First and foremost is that the Twins clearly focus on speed and defense more than most teams. Whether they do so successfully is up for debate, but when Nick Punto has the team's most middle-infield starts since 2002 and most third base starts since 2005 glove work and running fast are obviously priorities.
There are some exceptions, of course, particularly at third base, but even in the cases where the Twins attempted to sacrifice defense for offense they did so with non-sluggers. Third base has long been a power-hitting position and during the past 15-20 years more and more teams have viewed second base and to a lesser extent shortstop as a spot for guys with the power for 20-plus homers, but the Twins have never really come around to that approach.
Their shortstops and second basemen have almost always been diminutive players with a low strikeout rate, above-average speed, and below-average power, and that skill set rarely adds up to strong offensive production. They've been more willing to stray from that player type at third base in guys like Tony Batista, Mike Lamb, Joe Crede, Brian Buscher, Brendan Harris, and now Danny Valencia, but in none of those cases was there upside beyond solid regular.
As a tall, slow shortstop with 25-homer power Hardy is perhaps the most obvious example of the Twins going against their usual infield focus and not surprisingly they tired of him after just one year despite the highest OPS by a Twins shortstop since Guzman in 2001. Hardy's injuries were a big factor, but so was Gardenhire's desire to add speed to the infield. And now Hardy has 30 homers and an .800 OPS for the Orioles while Twins shortstops are back to not hitting.
Hardy and his .750 career OPS were sent packing because of injuries and lack of speed, while Valencia and his .735 career OPS are entrenched in the doghouse because of shaky defense and a general lack of awareness. Valencia is hardly a long-term building block, but he's a solid all-around player with a better bat than most Twins third basemen since Koskie and has plenty of value while earning the minimum salary.
It'll be interesting to see if the Twins ditch Valencia a year after ditching Hardy because neither player fits the organization's preferred infield mold and there's little indication they've realized how ineffective that mold is at finding competent hitters. Trevor Plouffe might be another test case, because in addition to possessing 20-homer power he's bigger, slower, and considerably less reliable defensively than the Twins like.
Trading away Hardy and replacing him with Tsuyoshi Nishioka showed a discouraging inability to properly evaluate those two players, but it also speaks to an overall approach to acquiring and developing infielders that's resulted in a decade of consistently awful offensive production from second base, shortstop, and third base. It's long past time to find infielders who can hit, but it remains to be seen if the Twins are capable of learning from mistakes and adapting.