March 23, 2011
Twins Notes: Fifth starters, old friends, bullpens, and short shelf lives
• Ron Gardenhire announced yesterday that Scott Baker will be in the rotation alongside Carl Pavano, Francisco Liriano, Nick Blackburn, and Brian Duensing, which means Kevin Slowey is bullpen bound despite a 39-21 record and 4.42 ERA in 82 career starts. Winning percentage is a mostly useless stat, but it's still notable that Slowey is headed to the bullpen with a .650 mark that ranks second to Johan Santana in Twins history among pitchers with 50 decisions.
I'm of the belief that both Baker and Slowey deserved rotation spots ahead of Blackburn, but with Gardenhire awarding Blackburn a starting job weeks ago that was clearly never an option and short of that Baker over Slowey is the right call. Baker is the longest-tenured member of the rotation and has a 4.33 ERA in 138 career starts, including a 4.49 mark in 29 outings last season after drawing the Opening Day assignment. He's a perfectly solid mid-rotation starter.
Slowey fits that description as well, but his durability has been in question since returning from late-2009 wrist surgery and there's been various speculation that the Twins aren't thrilled with his demeanor. It also likely didn't help Slowey's cause that he's not signed to a multi-year deal and is owed $2.7 million this season, whereas Baker is under contract for $11.5 million through 2012. To his credit, Slowey apparently took the demotion to the bullpen in stride yesterday.
Whether he'll be an effective enough reliever to gain Gardenhire's trust in a high-leverage role is unclear. Slowey has all of four career relief appearances, half of which came when he was a 23-year-old rookie in 2007, but has a 2.74 career ERA in the first inning and like most relievers the short appearances should help lessen the importance of his mediocre secondary stuff. As a reliever Slowey can focus on his fastball and slider while leaning less on his iffy changeup.
Of course, Slowey may not be long for the bullpen anyway. Rarely do teams make it through a 162-game season using just five starters, leaving Slowey just an injury away from being called back into rotation duty, and it wouldn't be surprising if teams have expressed trade interest in an affordable 27-year-old mid-rotation starter under team control through 2013. Shopping him seems natural, especially if they think No. 1 prospect Kyle Gibson will be ready by midseason.
• Dumped by the Twins and claimed off waivers by the Padres earlier this week, Pat Neshek flew from Florida to Arizona and tossed a perfect inning with two strikeouts yesterday. His first strikeout victim? None other than Carlos Gomez. Neshek is reunited with Jason Bartlett and Orlando Hudson, the latter of whom is already annoying new teammates with the same motor mouth that reportedly helped guarantee his departure from the Twins after one season.
• Alex Burnett was seemingly never viewed as a strong Opening Day bullpen option thanks to last year's second-half fade and he's been assigned to Triple-A. He jumped all the way from Double-A to the majors and then struggled in 14 appearances following a midseason demotion to Rochester, so some more time there at age 23 is probably a good thing. I'm still convinced Burnett can eventually be a solid bullpen contributor, perhaps this season.
• Burnett returning to Triple-A, Neshek going to San Diego, and Slowey moving to the bullpen did a lot to clear up the relief picture. Slowey joins Joe Nathan, Matt Capps, and Jose Mijares as locks, with Dusty Hughes and Glen Perkins looking like clear favorites to serve as second and third lefties behind Mijares. That would leave just one open spot, presumably for a righty, with Jeff Manship, Jim Hoey, Kyle Waldrop, and perhaps Carlos Gutierrez as candidates.
• Trevor Plouffe entered camp with at least an outside chance of pushing Matt Tolbert for the utility man job, but was 7-for-34 (.216) with seven strikeouts versus just one walk at the plate and was an absolute disaster defensively, making six errors in 16 games. He'll head to Triple-A for the fourth straight season, leaving Tolbert and Luke Hughes to duke it out for the backup infielder gig. For whatever it's worth, Hughes is in a 0-for-13 slump following a hot start.
• Last week I linked to a study showing that the Twins promote their position player prospects through the minors slower than every other organization and the first round of spring training cuts included a couple assignments that will add to those numbers. Chris Parmelee and Joe Benson were sent back to Double-A after playing 111 and 103 games there last year. Benson led New Britain in homers and OPS, so his repeating the level is the epitome of that study.
• Ben Revere spent last year alongside Benson in New Britain's outfield, but he was assigned to Rochester in a move that makes it very clear he'll be the first outfielder called up if needed. Obviously no surprise after Revere spent most of September with the Twins last year, but his moving up the ladder while Benson stays behind is interesting given that Benson topped his OPS by 128 points at Double-A. Revere is more polished than Benson, but has far less upside.
• There's been very little talk about left-hander Scott Diamond potentially making the Opening Day roster and Rule 5 picks must be sent back to their original team if they aren't kept in the majors all season, but the Twins reportedly may try to work out a deal with the Braves to keep him without the Rule 5 restrictions. He hasn't been impressive this spring, but Diamond has a chance to be a useful back-of-the-rotation starter or middle reliever at some point.
• Injuries to Frank Francisco and Octavio Dotel mean Jon Rauch looks likely to start the year as the Blue Jays' closer and the Twins kick off the season with a three-game series in Toronto.
• It was fun while it lasted, but Gardenhire is already too in on the whole "just fire it through the internet" thing for the humor to really continue much longer. Based on various beat writer accounts of his media briefings the past couple days, Gardenhire has been jokingly mentioning the internet, blogs, and Twitter seemingly every other sentence and has apparently also come up with his own set of accompanying sound effects. We'll always have the t-shirt, at least.
• Speaking of beat writers, Jon Marthaler of Twinkie Town put together some brilliant advice for Rhett Bollinger as he replaces Kelly Thesier at MLB.com.
I’m not big into all of the talk about Hudson not getting re-signed due to his mouth. In fact, I doubt it even factored into the decision. The Twins, especially Gardy, made it a point of emphasis in October or November to announce they wanted speed. I think we all appreciated Hardy and Hudson. They both hit pretty well and were consistent in the field, but I think that if Nishi and Alexi put up good OBP’s and steal bases effectively, we’ll forget about Hudson and Hardy pretty quickly.
Comment by Zach Morris — March 22, 2011 @ 11:46 pm
pretty big if there zach
Comment by tim pawlenty — March 22, 2011 @ 11:54 pm
Kind of like how Craig Kusick was going to make us forget about Harmon?
Comment by marietta mouthpiece — March 23, 2011 @ 6:59 am
I don’t normally read the links, but the linked Twinkie Town “advice” turned out to be excellent. Separate question: when do we get Ted Robinson back? I hear he is doing 25 games on radio.
Comment by David — March 23, 2011 @ 7:15 am
How can you not read the links?? That’s what makes Fridays so great! On a serious note, I think Hudson’s mouth is a big factor. I don’t think the Twins organization appreciated him wearing the Twinstripes while asserting that Jermaine Dye didn’t have an MLB contract because he is black.
Comment by Kopy — March 23, 2011 @ 8:17 am
Nishi has already made me forget about Hudson. Now Casilla on the other hand has been hitting worse than Punto this spring. Speed won’t help you if you can’t get on base.
Comment by Dave T — March 23, 2011 @ 11:20 am
What’s with this BS that about the Twins not liking ‘player x’s’ demeanor. I’ve heard it about Slowey, Neshek, Liriano, etc. Come on, the question should be, “does the guy perform well on the field or not?” This fixation on attitude by the Twins FO and coaching staff is ridiculous.
Comment by AK — March 23, 2011 @ 11:35 am
This fixation on attitude by the Twins FO and coaching staff is ridiculous.
Except a majority of it is at best innuendo by beat writers and at worst invented by the blogosphere.
Comment by John W — March 23, 2011 @ 12:48 pm
Marietta, I wouldn’t exactly compare Hudson and Hardy’s one average year here to The Killer’s legacy.
Comment by Zach Morris — March 23, 2011 @ 1:16 pm
@John W if that’s the case then so be it, but if it’s real, it’s stupid. All I care about is ‘can they throw/hit well?’
Comment by AK — March 23, 2011 @ 1:44 pm
Whether or not the attitude thing is as prevelant as thought,I’m glad Miguel Cabrera isn’t our star player. 🙂
Comment by Zach Morris — March 23, 2011 @ 1:58 pm
If we had Cabrera playing anywhere, the division would be guaranteed.
Comment by brian — March 23, 2011 @ 11:47 pm
I agree, Zach. I’m pleased the Twins are largely people you can feel okay rooting for. Just ask Mets fans these days.
Comment by doug — March 23, 2011 @ 11:50 pm
I’m pretty sure Mets fans want a winning team, regardless of whether it is made up of “people you can feel okay rooting for.”
Ultimately, I’m rooting for ballplayers, I don’t care how they are portrayed by the media or what they do off the field.
Comment by Brian — March 24, 2011 @ 1:14 pm
I guess I don’t care either, unless they’re engaging in behavior that jepordizes others lifes (i.e. drunk driving). Then I start to care a little bit. However, I think I made this conversation get a little off-topic. I blame the fact that I’m getting sick of spring training!
Comment by Zach Morris — March 24, 2011 @ 1:32 pm
Blackburn looked pretty good today against the Phillies. 6 innings, no runs, five strikeouts. IMO if he can pitch like this consistently (ground balls and strikeouts), he is a better pitcher than either Baker or Slowey.
Comment by Dave T — March 24, 2011 @ 4:37 pm
Blackburn would be a better pitcher than those two in everyone’s opinion if he could pitch like that consistently, Dave. Unfortunately, he doesn’t.
Comment by spookymilk — March 24, 2011 @ 6:36 pm