July 10, 2013
Old friends in new places: Catching up with former Twins pitchers
I've been getting lots of e-mails, comments, and tweets about seven former Twins being named All-Stars and ex-Twins in general thriving for other teams, so let's examine that notion. Like all teams the Twins cycle through tons of players every season, making it impossible to keep close tabs on everyone, but I've tried to narrow things down a bit by focusing on relatively prominent and/or oft-discussed players who departed the organization within the past handful of seasons.
Even then the list is a very long one, so today let's stick to the ex-Twins pitchers ...
• Joe Nathan: By declining a $12.5 million option the Twins made Nathan a free agent after 2011 and he signed a two-year, $14.5 million contract with the Rangers. At the time it would have been tough to justify a big two-year deal for a 37-year-old reliever still rounding back into shape after elbow surgery and his departure led to Glen Perkins emerging as closer, but Nathan has been amazing in Texas with a 2.25 ERA and 120/23 K/BB ratio in 104 innings.
• Francisco Liriano: Traded to the White Sox in mid-2012 for Eduardo Escobar and Pedro Hernandez as an impending free agent, Liriano wasn't much good down the stretch and then signed a two-year deal with the Pirates that was later reworked due to an offseason injury. He's been brilliant for the Pirates with a 2.20 ERA and 74/27 K/BB ratio in 70 innings, relying on his fastball less than ever before.
• R.A. Dickey: Dickey spent a thoroughly unmemorable 2009 season in Minnesota, serving as a mop-up reliever for 64 innings before refusing an assignment to the minors and leaving as a free agent. There was nothing promising about his performance, which included a 4.62 ERA and 40/32 K/BB ratio, and the Twins were hesitant to even use the knuckleballer with men on base. He inked a minor-league deal with the Mets at age 35 ... and turned into a Cy Young winner.
• Matt Guerrier: Guerrier exited as a free agent following the 2010 season for a three-year $12 million deal with the Dodgers after seven seasons in Minnesota. At the time Guerrier was 32 years old and showing obvious signs of decline, so the decision to let him walk was a sound one. He's struggled with injuries while posting a 4.20 ERA and was recently designated for assignment with a half-season left on the three-year deal, going to the Cubs in a swap of unwanted contracts.
• Jesse Crain: Crain followed Guerrier out the door after 2010, signing a three-year, $13 million deal with the White Sox. Despite a modest strikeout rate of 6.2 per nine innings he threw 382 innings with a 3.42 ERA in seven seasons in Minnesota, but Crain has racked up 10.6 strikeouts per nine innings while posting a 2.10 ERA in 150 innings for the White Sox. At the time I'd have re-signed Crain over Guerrier, but didn't blame the Twins for avoiding a three-year deal.
• Scott Baker: Baker missed all of 2012 following elbow surgery and then became a free agent when the Twins declined his $9.25 million option. They wanted to re-sign him to a cheaper deal, but balked when Baker refused to include a team option for 2014. He ended up signing with the Cubs for $5.5 million plus some incentives and has yet to pitch. Meanwhile, the Twins spent $4 million on a different pitcher coming off elbow surgery and Mike Pelfrey has a 5.63 ERA.
• Matt Capps: Capps went from making a combined $12 million as the Twins' closer in 2011 and 2012 to not even being able to get an MLB contract this offseason, settling for a minor-league deal with the Indians. Overall in two-and-a-half seasons in Minnesota he threw 122 innings with a 3.61 ERA and 5.4 strikeouts per nine innings, for which the Twins parted with the Nationals' starting catcher, Wilson Ramos, and $14 million while also forfeiting a compensatory draft pick.
• Kevin Slowey: Slowey's status a solid mid-rotation starter from 2007-2010 unraveled when he got pushed out of the rotation in 2011. Slowey didn't want to be in the bullpen, pitching horribly and getting injured, and the Twins did their best to tear him down while the local media was all too willing to lend a hand. He was traded to the Rockies for a non-prospect, missed most of 2012, and has returned the majors with a 3.99 ERA and 72/18 K/BB ratio for the Marlins.
• Jose Mijares: Cut loose after 2011 because the Twins decided a 27-year-old reliever with a 3.16 career ERA wasn't worth paying $750,000 via arbitration, Mijares wound up signing with the Royals for more money and then moved on to the Giants. Since leaving the Twins he has a 2.51 ERA and 88/30 K/BB ratio in 86 innings and still hasn't made more than $1.8 million in a season. Dropping him made little sense to me then and is certainly even more regrettable now.
• Jason Marquis: Marquis was as awful as a pitcher can be after signing a one-year, $3 million deal with the Twins last offseason, starting seven games with an 8.47 ERA and more walks than strikeouts while allowing opponents to hit .371 before they released him in late May. He quickly latched on with San Diego, where he pitched well and then re-signed for this season at $3 million. Overall for the Padres he's thrown 201 innings with a 3.90 ERA.
• Carl Pavano: Pavano had a good two-and-a-half season run for the Twins, but fell apart last year while unsuccessfully trying to pitch through a shoulder injury. He was finally shut down in June with a 6.00 ERA and didn't throw another pitch, leaving as a free agent. Pavano was looking for work as a back-of-the-rotation starter this offseason when he fell while shoveling snow and ruptured his spleen. He won't pitch this season and at age 37 might be done.
• Pat Neshek: Waived by the Twins in the spring of 2011 after struggling to come back from elbow surgery, Neshek was claimed by the Padres and split that season between Triple-A and San Diego with mediocre results. Last year he toiled away at Triple-A for Baltimore before a trade to Oakland, where Neshek has thrived again with a 1.91 ERA in 47 innings. There was really no good reason for the Twins to cut bait on Neshek, who now has a 2.91 career ERA in seven seasons.
• Craig Breslow: Breslow was a shrewd waiver wire pickup by the Twins in mid-2008, but after pitching well for 39 innings that season he struggled in early 2009 and they waived him. Not only was it an overreaction to a small sample of bad work, Breslow was cut loose so the Twins could call up a different left-handed reliever, Sean Henn, who lasted all of 11 innings for them. Since being lost on waivers Breslow has thrown 280 innings with a 2.93 ERA.
• Jon Rauch: Rauch was briefly the Twins' closer in 2010, filling in fairly well for a rehabbing Nathan by converting 21 of 25 saves with a 3.05 ERA. He lost the job when the Twins decided they had to overpay for a so-called "proven closer" in Capps and then left as a free agent that offseason, signing a one-year, $3.5 million deal. Rauch was decent in 2011 and 2012, posting a 4.12 ERA in 110 innings, but struggled this season and was recently released by two teams.
• Billy Bullock: Back in 2011 the Twins picked Scott Diamond in the Rule 5 draft, didn't want to keep him in the majors all year, and traded Bullock to the Braves for the right to send Diamond to the minors. I hated the deal at the time, because Bullock was a hard-throwing second-round pick and the Twins could have just kept Diamond as a mop-up man for nothing in return, but Bullock never harnessed his raw stuff and got released this month. Diamond has a 4.32 career ERA.
• Alex Burnett: For three seasons the Twins stuck with Burnett in their bullpen despite an increasingly poor performance, only to waive him this spring for no pressing reason. In the four months since then Burnett has been claimed three times off waivers, going from the Twins to the Blue Jays to the Orioles to the Cubs. Most recently he passed through waivers unclaimed and is now at Triple-A for the Cubs.
• Philip Humber: Acquired from the Mets as part of the Johan Santana trade, Humber never made a start for the Twins and appeared in just 13 total games before leaving as a minor league free agent. He had a good run for the White Sox in 2011 and threw a perfect game in April of 2012, but overall since leaving the Twins he has a 5.28 ERA in 322 innings. Humber is currently at Triple-A for the Astros after passing through waivers unclaimed.
• Jeff Gray: Gray won a spot in the Opening Day bullpen last year despite a lengthy track record of mediocrity and remained there for most of the season despite a 5.71 ERA and 26/22 K/BB ratio in 52 innings. When the Twins finally came to their senses and waived Gray he went unclaimed by the other 29 teams, became a free agent, and signed a minor-league deal with the White Sox. He's spent all of this season at Triple-A.
• Jim Hoey: Back in 2010 the Twins traded Carlos Gomez for J.J. Hardy and then a year later they traded Hardy for Hoey and Brett Jacobson. Whatever you thought of the Gomez-for-Hardy swap the Hardy-for-Hoey trade was a terrible, misguided idea that looks even worse now. Hoey threw 25 awful innings for the Twins, who lost him for nothing on waivers a year after the trade, and Jacobson was released from Double-A. Hoey is now playing independent ball.
This week's blog content is sponsored by Curt's Salsa, a locally owned salsa company that believes in fresh ingredients and rooting for the little guy. Please support them for supporting AG.com.
I’ve tried to narrow things down a bit by focusing on relatively
prominent and/or oft-discussed players who departed the organization within the past handful of seasons.
Grant Balfour hasn’t pitched for the Twins in nine years.
Comment by Aaron Gleeman — July 9, 2013 @ 10:33 pm
Dang- didn’t realize he’d been gone that long.
Comment by Kirk — July 9, 2013 @ 10:45 pm
So then why the snubs on Cuddyer and Gomez? I know you can’t do everyone, but if we want to kill the Twins with hindsight, wouldn’t we start there?
Comment by TMW — July 12, 2013 @ 9:16 pm
regarding what was given up for Matt Capps…that’s not even mentioning the welcome back T. Ryan gave us by forfeiting a supplemental first round pick in order to keep him when they could have signed any other guy and got the pick. Just couldn’t help himself when he saw the 4.66 K/9 in 2011. That decision alone soured me on this whole Ryan return…there was absolutely no rational reason for that.
Comment by Randy K — July 9, 2013 @ 10:46 pm
I would have preferred you had ended with Guerrier so it didn’t end on such a depressing note.
Comment by Sam — July 9, 2013 @ 10:54 pm
most of the regrettable pitchers leaving are relievers which we have lots of those now. Slowey and the knuckler (Dickey) are the two that would help the most right now. I don’t think Liriano would pitch as well here as he has in Pittsburg.
Comment by Doofus — July 10, 2013 @ 7:16 am
I can remember when Twins players who the left the team (free agents excepted) never played in the majors again, so some of this is progress, I guress.
Comment by funoka — July 10, 2013 @ 7:52 am
Aaron, I listen to you all the time and know you seem to be hesitant to say Gardy and the staff need to go, but it seems big changes need to be made, it seems the “Twins way” is not working anymore, we se to fail in growing young major leaguers? I also worry that Molitor, if he is who people think is the likely candidate will just continue the tired “twins way”mantra? Thoughts?
Comment by Chris — July 10, 2013 @ 8:02 am
This was one of my favorite posts you’ve written in a long time. Just goes to show how many poor decisions have been made over the past decade with this club. From the handling of Slowey, to the rediculous offer they posed to Hunter before he left, to how they handle (or don’t handle) injuries, etc. I haven’t been a fan of Gardenhire for many years but I’d be kidding myself if I thought he was the sole problem. While it was correct to call the Timberwolves a clubhouse environment, what the hell would you call the Twins? The organization never looks to hire from outside and to me it seems they promote mediocrity. Not sure about all of you but I’ve had my fair share. I don’t see how things get better as long as they continue this environment.
Comment by Bradley — July 11, 2013 @ 10:46 am
As an Indians fan, I too, lament the passing of Craig Breslow from the Tribe’s roster. He made seven appearances in 30 games (or so) before being waived. Thanks, Eric Wedge.
Comment by emd2k3 — July 12, 2013 @ 10:27 am
Aaron, this column might work better from a poker player’s perspective. The tone is a tad ‘Results-Oriented’ as the degenerates might say. The next time you do this you may want to section it off with ‘Thought Process’ and ‘Outcome’ for each player. That would mean evaluating the thought process behind releasing/trading/allowing a player to walk. Then the evaluation of the outcome that ensued.
Meh, nevermind. People are in a really negative frame of mind here and probably just want directions to vent that frustration. This format caters to that sentiment more easily.
Comment by TMW — July 12, 2013 @ 4:13 pm